I suppose it depends how you define "quality" - in my recent experience, it's always been the "rockstars" that are the worst developers. Because they generally write code which ends up being a nightmare to support and maintain when they're gone. Sure, it's great you wrote your own ORM in Perl but 10 years later it'll be crippling the company because no-one can make any changes without it breaking 27 other things.
(Ok, it's often Perl people...)
For me, a quality developer is someone who achieves the goals of the company in understandable, maintainable, testable, and documented code.