Even now sometimes I wonder is surgery a science? Does it use the scientific method?
Even now sometimes I wonder is surgery a science? Does it use the scientific method?
On the other hand, they are relatively to run and interpret. For a drug trial, you can give everybody a fixed dose of a drug (X mg; Y mg/kg bodyweight) in a fixed way (pill, injection, etc). Surgery is a lot harder to standardize. Along with the patient-to-patient variability, there's also surgeon-to-surgeon variability. Different surgeons might be faster or slower, cut more (and get a better visualization of whatever they're doing) or less (reduced tissue damage). Moreover, the individual surgeons improve with practice and it sometimes takes a lot (e.g., 100-200 knee arthroscopies) to plateau, which makes it tricky to evaluate a totally new method.
This is a nice paper discussing some of the issues in more detail: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5415901/
But I work in medical devices and I know for sure that there isn’t much data available of how well a procedure works. There is no centralized database that tracks outcomes. Most surgeons view a surgery as success if the surgery as such went well. They don’t do much tracking of whether the patient is doing better so there is risk they will keep doing surgeries that don’t really work. The manufacturer gets some information but also not much.
There definitely should be a countrywide or even better worldwide database of outcomes.
"""" “It is but fitting that a great medicus like you,” said Nello, adjusting the cloth, “should be shaved by the same razor that has shaved the illustrious Antonio Benevieni, the greatest master of the chirurgic art.”
“The chirurgic art!” interrupted the doctor, with an air of contemptuous disgust. “Is it your Florentine fashion to put the masters of the science of medicine on a level with men who do carpentry on broken limbs, and sew up wounds like tailors, and carve away excrescences as a butcher trims meat? Via! A manual art, such as any artificer might learn, and which has been practised by simple barbers like yourself—on a level with the noble science of Hippocrates, Galen, and Avicenna, which penetrates into the occult influences of the stars and plants and gems!—a science locked up from the vulgar!”
"""