And if things had become worse than now, how would that have impacted the economy?
And if things had become worse than now, how would that have impacted the economy?
The USA didn't lock down. Individual states locked down, at different rates. Some didn't lock down at all.
Take a look at the data and see if you can find a difference between the early and late lockdown states, particularly the ones that border each other.
I'm amazed at how blind people on HN are to the fact that the entire nation didn't take a homogenous approach to this at all. We have 50 different strategies that we're deployed.
Trying to tease out the data your asking for isn't possible due to inadequate reporting, inadequate testing, and the fact that travel between states is free.
Not all states locked down, at all. That matters. Travel between states, for the most part, fell to record low rates. This happened voluntarily, before legally mandated lockdowns were triggered.
You asked "what would have happened if we hadn't locked down."
I pointed out that not all places locked down, and many locked down later.
"Trying to tease out the data your asking for isn't possible due to inadequate reporting, inadequate testing, and the fact that travel between states is free"
It's not hard to look at the Johns Hopkins data set, which contains data at the county level for the US. Not much "teasing out" to do there. It's right there. If we use admitted cases as a benchmark for actual infections, assuming it's proportional at a relatively constant level, it's not hard to do.