How many times does a Tesla have to actively accelerate and careen into a solid concrete barrier before HN's modicum of skepticism for self driving, particularly Tesla's implementation, is justified?
But back when I lived in Colorado I had multiple times when I had to drive on a highway with completely obscured lines, poor weather, and extremely dangerous consequences for failure. I recall one drive in a blizzard where all the cars driving had to negotiate their own space without any feedback of where the lines were supposed to be. If I recall correctly we all settled on 1 fewer lanes than the road “should” have. I do not believe that self driving tech is capable of doing that yet, especially on mixed human/robot roads.
Personal experience with my model 3, two cases.
One, two lane road, flat, rain moderate to heavy, traffic in both directions, 55mph speed limit. I relied on the car to do most of the driving as oncoming lights from cars could make it hard for me to see, either had their brights on or misaligned. I could use the cars display out of the corner of my eye to see it knew the road lines
second, in fog, it certainly sees better than I do, more readily picking out the road and even detecting a vehicle in front of me whose lights were basically out.
still as I always say, with self driving I am a backseat driver sitting in the driver's seat.
Hackernews takes pride in being a data-driven, scientific community, except when it comes to Tesla self-driving, in which case everyone leans on personal anecdotes.
Long story short, it’s not feasible.
AGVs have been using wire guidance for years. You cut a notch in the floor, put in a wire, and fill in the notch. That's the technology GM used for the Firebird demo cars in the 1960s.
RFID tags are dead cheap, and would get cheaper if 100M were need to embed in road surfaces.
Sure, I’m sure there were complaints about the costs, but the value of a massive road network has been known for millennia.
Spending a trillion ripping up a perfectly good road network in order to try out a new technology that’ll generate profits for a small number of companies is an insane plan, and genuinely might not work.
I’m also not convinced it solves anything. In the scenario above the problem wasn’t the fact that the lines weren’t visible, the problem was other cars. This is particularly problematic when many of those other cars are human beings who will never have access to modified road information. In this scenario a smart car that knows where the lane should be is still forced to dynamically negotiate for space with other vehicles, sans communication protocols. That is a very hard problem, one I do not believe is currently solved.
1 accident every 50,000 miles is not a good record. I don't want 'self-driving' cars on the road that are only marginally better than the worst drivers out there.