And there comes a private company and gets whole teams and even patents and projects.
Wouldn't it be fair that tax payers also get something in return of their funding?
And there comes a private company and gets whole teams and even patents and projects.
Wouldn't it be fair that tax payers also get something in return of their funding?
What's the purpose of scientific funding: to progress science or to make money?
If the goal is altruistic progression of science, then undoubtedly that's best accomplished through free, nearly-unrestricted publication. That includes both work on nonpatentable fields (fundamental science, or advances too remote from commercialization for a patent timeframe to be viable) and not aggressively pursuing the full suite of IP protections for work that may be patentable.
If the goal is to make money, why should there be public funding in the first place? We don't ordinarily expect the government to run business ventures, and treating science funding like a Bell Labs writ large would be just such a business venture.
On the balance, the situation described in this article appears to be close to an optimal outcome: foundational science happened at a university, but a corporation came in with deep pockets and significantly more funding to work on the commercialization process.
What's the purpose of scientific progress if the people can't share in the benefits?
>but a corporation came in with deep pockets
Deep pockets partially because they domicile in tax-havens, and re-contribute the bare-minimum back to the source of the foundational science, forcing that foundational science funding onto the backs of the people, via trillions in student loans.
How is this "optimal"? Do you think we wouldn't be able to search the web without Google?
I definitely think we should push for fairer and more transparent public investment in science, but saying that all downstream benefits from publicly funded efforts cannot be privatized just seems to tilt incentives in the wrong direction.