HN won't let me reply to that, so I'll do it here. I didn't feel the need to offer a "defense" of Palantir there since I already outlined it above and don't feel like there's value in repeating myself.
But you asked, here you go - The government is going to use the data regardless, so long as they have it. The only effective recourse is to make them collecting or storing the data illegal, but good luck with that, seeing as even when it is illegal they do it anyways (see: Snowden).
Do you think is Palantir weren't there they'd just say "Ah well, I guess that's that" and be done with it? Nope; they'd go to Lockheed, Raytheon, IBM, or another long-time contractor to build a replacement almost immediately. The technology is genuinely nothing special. It federates searches across disparate database, and stitches results together.
But for me, having worked at Palantir, I know what mechanisms are provided to attempt to mitigate abuse. So as long as that data does exist and is going to be used, I'd prefer to have it be as well controlled and audited as possible. And sure, you can argue that the government may forego auditing, or be entirely corrupt, but that doesn't seem to me to be a good reason to not use tools that at least provide that capability.