Some hospitals in NYC were overwhelmed, but that was limited to Queens and Brooklyn: the NPR piece notes that Javits Center, which was turned into a hospital in Manhattan, treated about 1100 people total, after being built to handle 1900 at a time. The three other NY field hospitals on that list, all close to NYC, treated zero patients. One of those is in the same county just north of NYC that had the initial outbreak here.
I think there's no question that COVID-19 has been a disaster here, but it's going to be heavily debated whether the lockdown saved us or just made things worse on net.