It's not as bad of a nightmare as trying to explain the answer to the missing dollar riddle: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missing_dollar_riddle. That's an absolute nightmare.
It's not as bad of a nightmare as trying to explain the answer to the missing dollar riddle: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missing_dollar_riddle. That's an absolute nightmare.
That, in turn, is like the "Age of the Shepherd" problem[0] ... people just add/subtract/multiply/divide things randomly without thinking about what they mean.
[0] https://mystudentvoices.com/how-old-is-the-shepherd-the-prob...
I remember reading long ago (I'd love to find it again) about a CS department that gave a quiz to incoming students that was very predictive of their success. The answers they wrote didn't matter; what mattered was whether their answers evinced consistent meaning applied to terms and operations.
The paper: http://eis.mdx.ac.uk/research/PhDArea/saeed/paper1.pdf
Retraction: http://www.eis.mdx.ac.uk/staffpages/r_bornat/papers/camel_hu...
> Dehnadi, to his credit, stuck to his guns and did the meta-analysis that showed that he’d discovered a phenomenon and that his test was a worthwhile predictor.
The original paper contained several linked claims: that there is an ability to make consistent mental models, that it's intrinsic and fixed, that it predicts ability to program, and that few people have it, and hence few people can learn to program. AIUI, the debunked/retracted claims are that it's intrinsic and fixed, and that few people have it. It looks like the ability exists, but it can be learned, and it is linked to programming ability.
Which i think does line up with wcarey's point:
> The more I've taught math, the more convinced I am that getting people to "think about what they mean", and to think about what mathematical words mean is 90% of the project. [...] The answers they wrote didn't matter; what mattered was whether their answers evinced consistent meaning applied to terms and operations.
I won't go back and edit my comment, but what you say is true. There really is an interesting thing going on here, even if the original paper was an over-reach.
> In autumn 2005 I became clinically depressed. My physician put me on the then-standard treatment for depression, an SSRI. But she wasn’t aware that for some people an SSRI doesn’t gently treat depression, it puts them on the ceiling. I took the SSRI for three months, by which time I was grandiose, extremely self-righteous and very combative – myself turned up to one hundred and eleven. I did a number of very silly things whilst on the SSRI and some more in the immediate aftermath, amongst them writing “The camel has two humps”. I’m fairly sure that I believed, at the time, that there were people who couldn’t learn to program and that Dehnadi had proved it. The paper doesn’t exactly make that claim, but it comes pretty close. Perhaps I wanted to believe it because it would explain why I’d so often failed to teach them. It was an absurd claim because I didn’t have the extraordinary evidence needed to support it. I no longer believe it’s true.
A sad story :(
[0] https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/379927/how-long-wil...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mediant_(mathematics) https://www.cimat.mx/ciencia_para_jovenes/bachillerato/libro...
And hi Bjørn!
You can't have an operator for combining portions of groups with fractions alone, because 1/3 = 2/6. Combining groups of B boys and N people total, you get B1+B2 boys and N1+N2 people. Let's use @ for that operator, just to not distract from the usual addition. a/b @ c/d = (a+c)/(b+d).
Let's combine a group of 1/3 boys with a group of 2/3 boys. 1/3 @ 2/3 = 3/6. But 1/3 = 2/6, so that should be the same as 2/6 @ 2/3 = 4/9. But 3/6 isn't 4/9. You end up with this issue of a/b @ c/d = p a / p b @ q c / q d = (p a + q c) / (p b + q d), which can be anything. So we have the conclusion that if this operator makes sense, then all numbers are equal. You end up with a notion of numbers that is useless for the original problem of combining groups of people of different genders.
What we should do here is define it on pairs of numbers rather than fractions. A fraction and a total (p, N), or the number of boys and number of girls (b, g). The latter is super straightforward: (paul, jenny) + (bob, alice) = (paul and bob, jenny and alice), so numerically, it's (b1, g1) @ (b2, g2) = (b1+b2, g1 + g2), but (1, 3) is not (2, 6) here, unlike with fractions. Real simple. If we want to connect this back to the world of fractions, (p1, N1) @ (p2, N2) = (number of boys / total, total) = ( (p1 N1 + p2 N2)/(N1+N2), N1+N2 ). It's just a weighted average, so you need to keep track of the weights.
The equivalence operation is hard to master, and makes the arithmetic complicated.
This would also cause confusion, because combining 1/3 with 1/2 and 2/4 in this way would yield different results, even though 1/2 = 2/4.
You could then teach how to go from ratios to fractions by adding the ratio sides together and putting that in the denominator for each side... poof, you’ve invented averages!
No way someone would have come up with that approach on the fly, though.
1 + 2 - fine. 1/2 + 1/2 - one set of rules. 1/2 + 1/3 - a subtly different set of rules.
1:20 + 0:45 - yet another set of rules. Modular. 30° + 350° - fine? But maybe modular.
15% + 20% - who knows? 15% of what? 20% of what?
(1,2) + (2,4) - can't be done.
a^2 + a^2 - fine. a^2 + a^3 - nope. a^2 + b^2 - nope.
It would be lovely if mathematics were taught as a strongly typed language without overloaded operators, alas all our corpus is in the language it's in.
are you talking about points or open intervals? the notation is ambiguous ;) but addition of points is fine if you look at them as vectors
> a^2 + a^2 - fine. a^2 + a^3 - nope. a^2 + b^2 - nope.
what's wrong with the 2nd and 3rd ones? the 3rd one looks like half of Pythagoras theorem which is widely considered "fine" afaik ;)
The conversation with 16 year olds when you explain that their previous teacher who told them that you couldn't add points wasn't lying, but was, perhaps oversimplifying things to make their life easier, is a fun and fraught one.
I've had to reason kids through the fact that a^2 + b^2 is not equal to (ab)^2 or even (a+b)^2 more times than I can count. What's particularly difficult is that, confronted with the fact that 25 and 49 are manifestly different numbers, many still cling to the rule that a^2 + b^2 = (a+b)^2, because of the "law of distribution", which they haven't learned as the "law of distribution of multiplication of monomials over addition, and only that".
That's just notational sugar on fractions though (15/100, 20/100) - so why is that less troubling than the general case?
15% of 8 times 20% of 10 isn't 35% of any nice arithmetic combination of 8 and 10. That's hard to communicate to many students.
Another common, and I suppose related, one (but that I don't bother correcting often) is 'percent' != 'percentage point'. Talk of 47% of something being '3% less than' half of it really winds me up - and it's stupidly common among journalists - but it's too common to bother pointing out IMO. Live and let get wrong.
I think better to address the problem directly in fractions by saying that they're two different ways of combining them, addition and averaging, like the parent comment says. Feel free to make up a different symbol for the averaging operator, just let the kids know that it's not standard.
Arithmetic average or geometric average, to start.
I think the most basic answer to the “what do you do next” is unfortunately to explain they can’t do 1/3+1/3=1/6 but that why will be a future lesson.
The article gets a “fair” stopping point for the day at being mindful of the whole. And that you just can’t always add them.
Except that 1/3 + 1/3 = 2/3, not 1/6.
You probably just mis-typed, but in this context it's an interesting mistake.
> Except that 1/3 + 1/3 = 2/3, not 1/6.
That's why they can't do it.