1 + 2 - fine. 1/2 + 1/2 - one set of rules. 1/2 + 1/3 - a subtly different set of rules.
1:20 + 0:45 - yet another set of rules. Modular. 30° + 350° - fine? But maybe modular.
15% + 20% - who knows? 15% of what? 20% of what?
(1,2) + (2,4) - can't be done.
a^2 + a^2 - fine. a^2 + a^3 - nope. a^2 + b^2 - nope.
It would be lovely if mathematics were taught as a strongly typed language without overloaded operators, alas all our corpus is in the language it's in.
are you talking about points or open intervals? the notation is ambiguous ;) but addition of points is fine if you look at them as vectors
> a^2 + a^2 - fine. a^2 + a^3 - nope. a^2 + b^2 - nope.
what's wrong with the 2nd and 3rd ones? the 3rd one looks like half of Pythagoras theorem which is widely considered "fine" afaik ;)
The conversation with 16 year olds when you explain that their previous teacher who told them that you couldn't add points wasn't lying, but was, perhaps oversimplifying things to make their life easier, is a fun and fraught one.
I've had to reason kids through the fact that a^2 + b^2 is not equal to (ab)^2 or even (a+b)^2 more times than I can count. What's particularly difficult is that, confronted with the fact that 25 and 49 are manifestly different numbers, many still cling to the rule that a^2 + b^2 = (a+b)^2, because of the "law of distribution", which they haven't learned as the "law of distribution of multiplication of monomials over addition, and only that".
That's just notational sugar on fractions though (15/100, 20/100) - so why is that less troubling than the general case?
15% of 8 times 20% of 10 isn't 35% of any nice arithmetic combination of 8 and 10. That's hard to communicate to many students.
Another common, and I suppose related, one (but that I don't bother correcting often) is 'percent' != 'percentage point'. Talk of 47% of something being '3% less than' half of it really winds me up - and it's stupidly common among journalists - but it's too common to bother pointing out IMO. Live and let get wrong.