> It starts as soon as you visit, other speed tests don't, which violates a user's consent.
1) fast.com, 2) this feels like a reach, isn't "going to a speed test site" a pretty clear indicator of what the user intends to do?
> It gives wildly different results than other speedtests, with no explanation as to why.
I'm confused what your platonic ideal of a speed test is. Off the top of my head, I may care about:
* "speed to my ISP"
* "speed to something I care about that's 'nearby'" (fast.com to a Netflix box peered close to me)
* "speed to a CDN" (speed.cloudflare.com)
* "speed to a random data center somewhere" (speedof.me and friends)
* "speed to a box I own"
I'd be amazed if I didn't see significant deviation between all of those measures.