Plus this gives them more leverage over Intel on top of already being one of their biggest customers. I can't criticize an approach that puts the screws to them on price competitiveness.
Anandtech ran a pretty good article on the Graviton2 and its Neoverse N1 cores: https://www.anandtech.com/show/15578/cloud-clash-amazon-grav...
Yes. Cookie cutter SoCs stopped making money at around 65nm node. You need to put more on the table these days than just bare ARM cores and generic peripherals to sell a SoC.
Many dotcoms that ventured into chipmaking are now quietly bailing out.
Making your own chips just to undercut Intel is a stupid idea. People tried it before more times than I can count. Just remember all of RISC epopeias from nineties. Where are SPARC, PARISC, PPC, MIPS now?
The fact that they use ARM instead of any other RISC core makes little difference.
Internet companies are too small to make money from undercutting chipmakers, but I believe they are not that far away from that point.
Maybe in 10 years or so, you will be working on a PC with Genuine Google(R) chip
If AMD can profitably build and sell a state of the art CPU in the world with that scale, why couldn't the cloud companies be able to?
That's easy to say, now think of why other companies with n-times money "can't simply do that"?
It takes quite a lot of effort, and skill: execution capability. GAF companies are easy money companies, they, and their executives are not made for that.
Given you've pivoted away from the economics to claiming that they just can't do it, how do you explain the results from this article? Shouldn't Amazon have been too incompetent to build a state of the art server CPU? How about Google's TPUs, in-house switches, and in-house NIC ASICs? Just failed prestige projects?
I think a particular fruit company would disagree?
On the other hand, it wouldn’t have made sense for Apple to design their own chips for Macs, but they sell 200-250 million ARM based devices a year.
No amount I can imagine can pay off for the tapeout on the latest node for them. All dotcoms taken together make for single digit percentage of wafer output for both Intel, or AMD.
Apple doesn't make money on chips, they make money off their devices. An A13 may well not make them money, but the whole Iphone does.
Apple has always been about limiting SKUs to maximize their economies of scale. The original iMac was a great example of this... although they had no market share, they had like 3 SKUs vs HP and Dell who had dozens or hundreds of different PCs. It was the biggest selling model of computer at the time, and they make money on it because of that scale.
They do the same thing with the iPhone today. The SE has the same guts as the flagship SKU, which is in turn faster than any competing product. The control of the roadmap and capabilities of the CPUs is a huge competitive advantage that makes a lot of money. They save money on things they don’t control like batteries because the faster CPU uses less power, etc.
Everyone else is stuck with whatever garbage Qualcomm is dishing out.
Amazon is in a similar place. There remains a lot of on-premise server compute that AWS wants to conquer. You need to think about their actions today in terms of what they mean in 2030.
I don't think the battery/CPU relation you posit is true - the A13 is faster in single-core performance than the Snapdragon 865 (or 855), but consumes more total power to do the same work: https://images.anandtech.com/doci/15207/SPEC2006_S865.png
I think all this tells you is that ARM's big cores chose a power/performance curve point well below the A13. The upcoming Cortex-X1 in next year's 875 will be their first attempt at breaking into that market.
Mobile CPUs usually have low power and high performance modes, and aggressively shed power loads when idle. I’m not sure what benchmark is appropriate, but I wouldn’t draw much from that one.
Most compute workloads are the same, and the sorry state of the legacy hardware companies is testament to that. HPE sold off its field services to Unisys, the Dell conglomerate exists (owing to the collapse in valuation of once mighty EMC), IBM is whatever IBM has become, etc. Oracle essentially doesn’t pay salespeople for selling traditional software.
At some point, more enterprise workloads just won’t be feasible anywhere but cloud. The stupid government or a bank will pay a few FTEs to swap parts for $1M/year, but everyone else will have moved to cloud.
But, we also aren’t talking about all chips. Just server class chips. Energy cost is also a very real cost at the scale of the cloud vendors. If they can decrease the overall cost and the cost/per watt. It’s a win.
Source?
And I strongly suspect Apple's been doing the same with ARM MacBook prototypes since A8X, if not before...
Speculation aside, it's pretty cool to see an ARM core competitive at this scale at the socket level.