We have good evidence that 2 metre distancing works.
We strongly think that mask wearing is effective, but we fail to find benefits from mask wearing when we run RCTs.
We have a government who has been pushing a herd immunity strategy (even if they dropped that phrasing) and this kind of thing just makes that clear.
"Japan, which has the third highest rate of transit ridership in the world, found no infection events linked to commuter trains after performing rigorous contact tracing on almost 17,000 confirmed cases."
From the article you linked:
"Oshitani says riders are usually alone and not talking to other passengers. And lately, they are all wearing masks. “An infected individual can infect others in such an environment, but it must be rare,” he says."
Tokyo has benefitted from both a fall in the volume of passengers on the Metro, and an infection rate of 0.5 per capita. The virus is more than 500x as prevalent in the UK as a whole, and more than 600x as prevalent in London.
Do you have a reason to believe greater prevalence of the virus is linked to lower mask effectiveness in this specific context?
There simply are no infected people on Japan's transit, due to the country's intensive, early quarantining procedures. (same with Korea and Taiwan)
I think important to note that no serious person could or would ever claim that masks are "100% effective". You're drawing this conclusion from the absence of outbreaks on a depleted Tokyo metro and (although you don't mention it) Paris too.
It isn't possible to legislate for manufacturing defects in masks, suboptimal storage conditions, wearing it incorrectly, etc. That's before you even get to the myriad confounding variables which stem from different cultures AND weigh the fact that you're drawing your conclusion -- which will result in preventable deaths, if it's wrong -- from an absence of evidence to the contrary (!).
The article you linked and many others on this topic highlight that Japan adopted a "three C's strategy" which has led to social distancing on the Metro in addition to masks (which were already a popular facet of commuting in Tokyo). So just like London, they're doing social distancing and wearing a mask.
Worth observing that New York's mask-wearing MTA employees have been disproportionately blighted by COVID-related mortality[1], and London's bus drivers aren't faring (ha) much better[2].
> Do you have a reason to believe greater prevalence of the virus is linked to lower mask effectiveness in this specific context?
I didn't suggest that the virus being more prevalent lowers the effectiveness of masks. I pointed out that prevalence is more than 600x higher in London than Japan. The Tokyo Metro transports around 7m passengers per day, which yields 35 infected passengers on the system each day (0.5 per capita). TFL moves 9 million passengers each day, with a 333 per capita instance of COVID-19 infection, which means nearly 30,000 infected individuals.
If masks are 100% effective when worn properly, but 10% of the time are either defective or worn improperly, a peak journey in Tokyo would expose 700,000 people to risk from 3.5 COVID carriers. You could express this as a ratio of 200,000 at risk of contracting for every 1 person at risk of spreading the disease. In London the same math sees 900,000 people exposed to risk from 3,000 people. The ratio becomes 300:1.
When you consider it in these terms it doesn't seem imprudent to reduce capacity AND insist on masks. At least until there are more meaningful data to support decision making.
[1] https://www.thecity.nyc/2020/6/1/21277407/nyc-subway-crews-h...
[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/02/world/europe/coronavirus-...
People with symptoms who stay at home are going to infect far fewer people than people with symptoms who wear masks and travel.
the thing is no one fully understand how this virus spreads, who is at risk, what exactly is the right course of action
so they latch on whatever the latest fad is,
it used to be lockdown, then it became social distancing, but then the riots came and cases did not go up, now it is facemasks that save us all
Besides how could you be socially distant in the military and on an aircraft carrier...
it is akin to respecting someone's space.
also, it's about a threshold reduction of risk, as zero risk is practically impossible and counter-productive.