[0] https://www.staradvertiser.com/2020/05/21/hawaii-news/dozens...
I fail to see how the claim is ridiculous.
These people were accused of crimes, which is different.
Also, unless they were convicted of previous crimes, they weren't "criminals".
* Person A and Person B commit an identical crime.
* Person B is released because they have 10,000$ for bail
* Person A doesn't have 10,000$ and because of this they cannot work and instead must stay in jail
The point is that people don't consider Person A dangerous, and the only difference is how much money they have access to - so why is Person B dangerous and not A?
Not even this. They are alleged to have committed the crime, but have not been tried in court.
A & B might both be dangerous. I would rather have 100 on the street instead of 200.
Nothing like taking "the poor" off the streets and then keeping them in jail because they don't have family who, even if they have money in the first place, can take time off work to go down to the courthouse and to deliver a bail.
Also, person A _might_ be dangerous is in some way putting at least part of the punishment before conviction - IMO that should be very carefully considered, and I don't see how monetary means is a large part of that.
You should then also oppose bail. So that the people you believe dangerous can't just "buy" their way out.
Many people would disagree with you on the danger level, but I'm not sure why you're making an argument against people complaining about the concept of bail.
There are cases where the defendant is in jail pending trial gets a bail set and can’t afford it, then gets a plea that would result in his release so he takes it...but that in no way is the primary purpose of the bail to force the plea. I don’t think you would ever find such a case where the defendant hasn’t waived their right to a speedy trial. But feel free to link such a case.
Instead we see people who are very poor getting five digit bails, and instead languishing in jail because they can’t afford bail.
Pre trial detention should be based on the public good, and that is clearly not what we have today.
Nearly 40% of all defendants out on bail are ROR (no money required). Maybe it should be more or “more aggressive”, but few in my experience know that much or what ROR even is.
Bail is otherwise pretty uniform (within each jurisdiction) based on the charges (sometimes a defendants past charges will be considered in the amount as well as ability to abscond).
I see your point about matching the bail to the defendants resources...but it would just encourage attempts to abscond and skip trial. I was the victim of a kidnapping and the defendant got bail ($350k or so) and posted bond (paid 10% to a bondsman and they postEd the full amount). In reality the defendants mom posted the bail, the amount (even though not his money) was a deterrent for skipping trial, but he had nothing so if the amount was say $350 instead of $350k there would be no reason for him not to attempt to abscond, but even he wouldn’t run and harm his own mother financially. Still within 7 days Of posting bail and being released he violated the terms of his bail and was rearrested anyway.
For minor crimes (and in some places major crimes) they go to jail; the main jail/prison distinction in the US is that the former tends to be city or county and include pretrial detention and the latter tends to be state or federal and exclude pretrial detention. But jails, while they include pretrial detention, also include people serving sentences.
> The state has to actually prove beyond a shadow of a doubt that you, the accused, committed the crime.
No, the required proof is beyond a reasonable doubt.
If you release more, you have more suspect dangerous criminals on the streets.
>Although the Eighth Amendment protects against excessive bail, there is not an absolute right to bail, as noted in The Bail Reform Act, 18 USC Chapter 207 (1984). Section 3142 of the Act denies bail to certain defendants pending trial, specifically denying bail to defendants likely to flee or pose a danger to society.
If they were arrested then statistically speaking they are far more likely than the average person to be criminals.
I feel like one of the ultimate sources of tension in western society today is that one side puts far too much faith into the good in people, a perspective that can only come from ivory tower privilege. This comment is a perfect example.
Sure, those who disagree will claim that the real problem is the opposite, but my point is that the side of the protestors lacks nuance in their worldview; often people are bad and you can't just blindly blame society for every criminal.
That was never the comparison - the bit you didn't quote was "than those who had bailed out for the same crimes". According to your argument, they are _also_ more likely than the average person to be criminals, yet we bail them out.
Or just have the wrong skin complexion. Getting arrested doesn't increase one's chances of being a criminal, that's not how reality or statistics work. It just increases their chance of being in jail by about 100% but they still have very much the same chances of being a criminal as they did right before being arrested.
What's an alternative proposal for how to tilt the balance of incentive/disincentive so that they do not go on the run?
Or is the whole question malformed and ill-conceived?
The solutions are always easier said than done. This is an institutional and societal problem and one that other western societies managed to work around. Of course taking them as a model is considered insulting so here we are.
However, the police/DA can accuse an innocent person of a serious crime. You should not be imprisoned before you are sentenced unless that is the only way to make you show up for trial. I.e., it should not be about the severity of the crime, but about how much of a flight risk you might be.