That's hardly enough time or data to tell what the actual mortality rate is full cycle. A lot of startups will fail in year 6, 7 or 8 after years of pivots and trying to grow.
> On average, they’re growing 100% in the first year, and 300% the second year
Assuming $0 in rev on day 1, of course they grow 100% in Y1. These numbers don't mean anything.
Philosophically I agree with Indie.vc. I think there is untapped potential in smaller companies/markets that mostly is overlooked by traditional VC. But I don't think VC is the answer to that problem. There needs to be some other funding vehicle that can withstand smaller returns over longer periods of time (like a loan, which this seems to be closer to).