A "C" coder is someone who writes bad code. It's relatively easy to detect and fire a "C" coder.
A "B" coder is one who for the most part writes good code, but doesn't design a good long-term architecture, or makes many small mistakes that add up in the long run, or leaves the code riddled with small bugs that eventually cause frequent problems. The "B" coders are the dangerous ones because really you should fire them or fix them, but it's too easy to ignore them.
An "A" coder writes solid code and is dependable, but doesn't hit the high notes, as Joel Spolsky says.
A star coder is an "A" coder who hits the high notes.
(I don't know what a "D" coder is, but perhaps our scales are offset by one letter grade.)