Of course people should disagree, experience dialectics, have conversations, debate, spar, parry, and enjoy rigorous conversation.
But then there are sentiments that are beyond the pale. Should NAMBLA be allowed a late night talk show, or an NYT editorial to espouse their views? Should neo-nazis be given a soapbox, or even worse, access to a highly-targeted ad network to radicalize young men? Should Richard Spencer be punched in the face for being a bigoted piece of human garbage?
Should I be allowed to call him that? Is violence ever justified?