1. Do whatever you were doing in the past and worked well for you.
2. Copy what other people are doing and it seems to work well for them.
3. Try to figure out what is the best decision yourself.
I think different people (heck, even same people at different situations) have different propensity to choose one of these options. And it makes sense, to save option 3 only for special occasions.
But what if the group orthodoxy is just an illusion created by all the people who choose option 1 and 2? And the contrarian happens ad hoc, by being the person who for whatever reason chooses option 3?