In practice, it's a failure every time.
Not every sin need be taxed.
https://www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/politics/the-evidence-is-...
In practice, it's a failure every time.
Not every sin need be taxed.
https://www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/politics/the-evidence-is-...
The study literally came to the opposite conclusion:
> Three types of taxation on sugary drinks lower healthcare costs, cardiovascular disease, and diabetes, but some – such as taxing sugar content – perform even better than taxing based on the volume of the beverage.
I had hoped that the article would be about real world results, but it's really about comparing different results theoretically. Which is also helpful, but not nearly so helpful as data.
Actually gathering data is hard. The effects of sugar in the diet take decades to show up, and there are millions of variables and compounding factors. So it's not really a surprise that the article is theoretical rather than practical, but it is disappointing that the headline doesn't make that more prominent.
The real-world experiments will be policy, and those policies will have to be driven by these models ahead of there being experimental results. So we have to do it. But we won't know how good they were for a long time.
Absolutely... as long as every individual is willing to pay the full costs of their sins.
Making each and every individual responsible for the cost of their own "sins" completely removes society's responsibility for creating the circumstances in the first place.
A lot of these issues are offloaded to healthcare. It is the government's job to figure out strategies to reduce the load on healthcare systems. It's definitely a hard problem to solve, it could all end up in a failure, but it's important to discuss it before stamping "FAILURE" on it. Maybe there are good strategies that do work?
To give an example of what works: when I was young we had many lessons about what smoking does to you. We discussed the effects of it and were shown pictures of gnarly lungs. That, plus how my parents smelled after smoking, definitely helped me make up my mind about smoking. Sugar is way more difficult than that, as you get addicted to it before you ever realize the effects of it. After years of just eating sugary foods and drinks, regular food starts to taste bland. I remember as a kid I hated the taste of water - how insane is that?!
A tax is a worthwhile strategy to explore in my opinion.