I’m more concerned about routine, predictable care (even expensive but schedule-able surgeries like knee replacements) that are gouging our entire system. We need drastic decrease in costs in this area which I believe is achievable in part through price transparency and “shopping around”. Indeed, the medical tourism industry, where Americans fly to foreign countries for medical and dental procedures, exists for this exact reason.
Medicine is not entirely the same as other markets but pretending it is somehow entirely disconnected from basic economics is how we got into this mess in the first place.
Who cares about ideology here. There’s a lot of evidence this lowers the cost of elective surgeries. This is great for those with and without insurance and might drive the price down. This ruling in now way hurts the public option unless you see this as a zero sum game where any improvement to the health care system without an overhaul is bad politically. I’m in favor of the public option and this ruling.
Trauma? Death or multiple orthopedic and cardiothoracic/neural surgeries.
Heart attack? Death or multiple specialist visits, possibly surgical intervention.
Stroke? Same thing.
Respiratory failure, punctured/collapsed lung, deep vein thrombosis, etc.? Same thing.
Sure, the person who comes to the ER for a cold has the time to figure out which ER to go to, buy a large majority of major (read: expensive) hospital visits are time critical life or death. Delaying treatment of a heart attack or stroke massively decreases survival rates and those are two of the most common causes of death in the US already.
Outside the US, many of these aren't the most expensive ones. Furthermore, "multiple surgeries" and "multiple specialist visits" might be caused by an emergency, but are very rarely scheduled as an emergency - the first one, maybe; the rest usually have 48 hours to 14 days in between (which often cannot be shortened for medical reasons even if you wanted). The patient might not be able to comparison shop between while recovering, but their spouse/kids/parents likely could. Also, many of those emergencies cause weeks or months of hospitalization - but often moving to another hospital is medically reasonable, and if it cuts the cost of care down 50%, many people will prefer it over e.g. bankruptcy.
The mere possibility that people will shop around tends to make a market much more fair.
And additionally, on average emergency care, even if more expensive, is small in the grand scheme of things. Continuous treatments and medications, and pre-planned procedures are the majority of the overall costs.