What data do you think they will exfiltrate that's so important that you go through the effort of setting of VMs and whitelisting?
Do you ban your family from using social media as well due to data collection?
What data do you think they will exfiltrate that's so important that you go through the effort of setting of VMs and whitelisting?
Do you ban your family from using social media as well due to data collection?
Asking "what data do you think they will exfiltrate?" assumes that the only reason to oppose telemetry is "they might see something I want to keep hidden". But, as it's often said when it comes to other people attempting to cross your personal boundaries, "'No' is a complete answer".
I love that, so important!
Have people seen the Tea consent video? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oQbei5JGiT8
Eh? Why would that be ok? I think it's worth asking them why they don't want it anymore. If they continue to say no, do you really think it is ok to start pouring it down their throat?
Consent can be revoked at any point in time.
For what it's worth I think most cultures today are crap at consent. I think many of us are victim to a pre-#MeToo culture where sexual harrasment was somewhat more socially 'acceptable' or 'accepted' [1][2]. I think of the memes of women who seem uncomfortable when Biden touches them. Dr. Bessel van der Kolk talks about his desire for a 'trauma-conscious' society.
To me there is no denying that often we have been hurt, and that there is not enough support for many people out there. I believe we don't get the support that we would need to heal from these things. Walking around hurt and unhealed is unfortunately the norm.
> That's a cute way to talk through the ideas
Rape and sexual assualt are very common, so I think this video is more than 'cute'; it's essential. I hope we start showing this to kids at a younger age, to help them grow boundaries early on. This also concerns consent for non-sexual contact such as hugs, or just any other type of physical contact with another person.
[1] women: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wWoP8VpbpYI [2] men: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uc6QxD2_yQw
I mean that "come on, you got me to make this tea, at least have a sip" is perfectly fine to say about actual tea. In the analogy, doing that is not good.
(Assume this is a situation where they don't have a specific reason, so asking why they don't want it is completely nonproductive.)
> DECIUS BRUTUS: Most mighty Caesar, let me know some cause, Lest I be laugh'd at when I tell them so.
> CAESAR: The cause is in my will: I will not come; That is enough to satisfy the senate.
Now that I use "no" though, I still have people that ask "why" after it. Can't really tell them "this is the way" :)
But an example that I once used to explain to my wife why I don't trust TikTok and whatnot:
Some time ago (I obviously won't say when) we interacted with a person, that had a bounty on his head, setup by Boko Haram, and people DID tried to kill him before. What if for example we had filmed him and that information leaked or got intercepted?
Me, and my wife, have no enemies, done nothing illegal, and so on, nothing to hide personally, but about other people we interact with? What if some day a friend on internet, maybe a gaming buddy, tells me a important secret out of the blue because he needs urgent help, and that secret gets intercepted?
Suppose you will forevermore remain a boring person who never has anything to hide. So you knowingly use spyware, because you're an open book.
That enables common software to be spyware. If people are willing to use it knowing full well what it is, it continues to exist and be popular. Then people who do need privacy for legitimate reasons don't realize that, or don't have any good alternatives because the better options are niche and make them stick out like a sore thumb. And then dissidents get killed.
Don't get dissidents killed. Just Say No to The Cloud.
Blur your face if you wish.
There is no danger for you. No data I can use against you.
Will you do it?
Most people would not.
What you decide to be private is, just because you decide it.
MS doesn't get to decide that.
These days it's a grown-ass market with competition and much more advanced toys involved. You turn on water, they know timings and how much you used. You use more electricity, they call you to suggest a different plan. You used drugs and flushed, they find metabolites in sewerage sensors (I heard that on news, dunno maybe bs).
So I think it's basically about bills; cameras in toilets are different market.
Would you find comfortable if while eating at the restaurant with your SO, a waiter sat at next table constantly staring at you two, and taking notes on what you eat, how you do it, in how much time and how much you appear to have enjoyed it, possibly also by analyzing your words? Stupid example maybe, but that would be just one of the many exact equivalents in real life. Don't tell that to toilet manufacturers:)
I probably won't run for anything, but just in case.
- The Finnish army did not have doors at their toilets before they got a female defense minister who obviously shocked by that practice ordered that doors need to be installed.
- In 2008 I visited New York City while suffering from stomach problems (We had bought the tickets months before.) While strolling around near Washington square I urgently needed to visit a toilet. I run to Washington Square and into the public restrooms there, to make the shocking discovery that there were no toilet cabins. It was just a big room with several toilet bowls and of course I was not alone. But there was no choice: It's the pants or the (semi-) public toilet bowl. (It remained unclear whether the setup was a result of vandalism or a prevention of vandalism or what)
I'm neither Finnish nor American and I found both learnings pretty shocking. But obviously it's just a cultural thing what is shocking and what not.
That said I am not happy that spying on users, whether its Android apps or Microsoft telemetry is seen as culturally acceptable instead of shocking by a majority of the public today.
You can be curious, but it's not on the OP to have to argue why he cares. Microsoft should not exfiltrate anything without asking for explicit permission, and honor a blanket refusal without exception. That the OP has to go through extreme countermeasures to prevent this leeching is unacceptable.
>Do you ban your family from using social media as well due to data collection?
This logical fallacy rhetoric is known as a whataboutism [1](an attempt to discredit an opponent's position by charging them with hypocrisy without directly refuting or disproving their argument)
I'd like to say I have a rational justification based on risk/reward analysis, but I don't have enough information or time to really do that.
Honestly, it's more visceral. They repeatedly try to deceive people to pry away their private information. I want it to stop, and (probably to my discredit) I have strongly vengeful fantasies against the perps.
> "Do you want to eat some cake?"
> "No"
That's a very reasonable question and answer.
> "Why don't you want some cake?"
You might think it's reasonable to ask why someone doesn't want cake. I think it's prying. The first time it's asked, okay, fine.
> "Would you want some cake if it was chocolate?"
You're still asking about cake when the person said no.
> "Do you not like sprinkles?"
Why are you trying to conflate sprinkles with cake?
> "I can help you eat it better if understood why you didn't want it."
Seriously. You're building a pattern of abuse here.
"No" is a complete answer for permission. Trying to get around that "no" is malicious and abusive.
To me, his/her first question just showed interest in the perspective I'd posted.
I took @jonax's later questions as a kind of Socratic questioning. Which can come across as either a way to help sharpen one's position on a topic, or as an unwelcome display of skepticism, depending on the audience. I assumed the former.
If I had to criticize that post for something, it would be that it made wrong assumptions about how I'd answer that first question. So the subsequent questions weren't really on point.
Cake is a personal taste. Are technical choices a question of taste. Your arguing against debates and technical discussions.
It's telling that many examples given were using video feed or pickpockets as an analogy to telemetry. These are not interesting explanations. Going to extreme arguments is not illuminating.
I've mostly stopped this approach though, because it makes people doubt that I'm having the discussion in good faith.
Nonsense. Using cake instead of privacy is making it less extreme than the original.
Personal data.
It's not okay for them to take data like this.
No-one (at least yet) is running FacebookOS.
And yes, this analogy is admittedly a weak one, because while your particular brand of car does have locks on its doors, the manufacturer didn't give you the key.