I would expect the thing to be over rather swiftly, albeit probably with some accretion disc still generating some radiation.
Black holes don't just vacuum up all the matter around them silently. Any matter falling into a black hole, not just the accretion disk, emits radiation. This radiation causes surrounding matter to expand outward, counteracting the gravity of the black hole. A black hole trying to eat an entire star at once will quickly exceed its Eddington limit [1] and most of the remaining matter will be blown away.
A star would be unlikely to directly enter an event horizon but would instead orbit the black hole (with resulting doppler-shift accelerations detectable on Earth via spectral analysis), and strong emissions from IR to x-ray frequencies as matter was ripped from the star by tidal forces and drawn into the event horizon.