Again, you're still limiting your perspective to some very specific, niche, and frankly unusual industries, and looking at them in isolation. Most industries don’t and can’t have a
"loose community of individual contributors and companies of all sizes." The 3D printing industry is unusual in that it has a very low cost of entry, and many of the primary consumers have the skills to directly contribute to the further development of the technology, and an intellectual interest in doing so.
You’re also still ignoring that 3D printing and Open Hardware would not exist without the trillions of dollars in capital investment made in all the underlying technologies. Investments that would have been an insanely risky propositions without IP protections.
Can you explain how the multi-billion/trillion-dollar research and development in jet engine design, commercial refrigeration, medical devices, drugs, microcircuit manufacturing, industrial mechatronics, etc, can be accomplished by the private sector, without legal protection to allow for a ROI? Can you find an example of someone developing Open Hardware who is making large enough profits to build their own semiconductor R&D labs and foundries?
And again, I’m not saying that there aren’t a lot of problems with patents. I fully agree there are. As you said, “hostile patent enforcement” (meaning forcing a company to defend itself against vague and often entirely invalid patents), is a serious problem. But that’s an argument for patent reform, not abolishment. Unless you can come up with an alternative way to protect the huge-to-astronomical R&D investments many industries require.
Also, to be blunt, thinking that “mega-corps trivially reimplementing open innovation, and then failing commercially because everyone hates them and doesn't trust them enough to work with them” applies to anything outside tiny niche and industry-internal markets is frankly silly. The general public will buy the next shiny new toy from whichever mega-corp has the best marketing. Serious industrial operations always prefer to buy from bigger companies as it reduces various sources of complexity and risk (this is an area I know firsthand and can go into detail on). It’s very rare that anyone cares who originally invented the technology. And regarding your last point -- without patent enforcement, no small company developing a functionally better technology would even exist to be attacked. Nobody would invest in starting a company if there was no way to stop the incumbent from reverse-engineering the improved tech before the start-up gained any market traction, adding it to their products, and crushing competition through price, marketing, and existing consumer network (again something I can talk about firsthand if you'd like to continue this off HN).