Beyond that this is unprecedented times/circumstances so it's really difficult to make general conclusions about this "experiment."
Beyond that this is unprecedented times/circumstances so it's really difficult to make general conclusions about this "experiment."
Yeah, I received "relief income" from the government, i.e. my own tax dollars, even though I'm not unemployed, and am actually saving money by not having to commute.
If this is "universal income", I fail to see how creating a massive government bureaucracy to take my money and then give it straight back to me is beneficial to anyone except bureaucrat middlemen performing glorified ditch-digging jobs.
Huh? This whole program was put together and executed in a matter of days, and mostly via the bureaucracy of the IRS as I understand it.
The point of a UBI is in part that it is explicitly not means tested to avoid "welfare trap" incentives, and it's tremendously cheap to implement relative to, say, food stamps or what's left of cash welfare in the US.
"Means-testing"—as in welfare programs—specifically refers to payouts that have cliffs, that create bad incentives like people choosing to not get jobs because they'd lose access to the welfare payment, and end up with less money than they get with no job.
Progressive taxation has no cliffs; there is never† a tax-related reason to refuse to take a higher-paying job. You'll always be able to keep some of the additional pay. Thus, it's not "means-tested."
† Unless there's a 100% tax bracket. But I don't think there's any country that bothers with these, because of the clearly-wonky disincentives.
means-testing doesn't imply cliffs, only checking (e.g., 'means' of otherwise survival) before providing.
progressive application is simply the continuous form of means-testing, rather than discontinuous cliffs (which are conceptually simpler, but create adverse incentives).
frankly, every fiscal program should phase in/out with income/wealth over the whole range (i.e., be universally progressive), rather than discontinously and/or regressively (e.g., payroll taxes).
in this regard, UBI simply says that instead of just being continuous, let's also make the payout function a constant.
This is usually true but not always.
Where I live, if you as a self-employed contractor make revenue over the VAT threshold you must start charging VAT.
If the clients are VAT registered business, they won't mind, they can reclaim it. But if they are not VAT registered, or if they are regular people not businesses, your price will effectively increase by 20% for them.
To avoid losing business with the people who cannot reclaim the VAT, you may decide to lower the prices you charge to compensate.
That's a cliff. You can be better off turning down a higher-paying job (such as a 3 month contract) that would put you over the VAT threshold, if you are close to it and would have to lower prices to everyone else to compensate, depending on your line of business.
In the US, sales tax is a bit like VAT in the EU.
As with VAT, there's a registration threshold, and if you reach it you may need to lower your prices to end customers.
The sales tax registration threshold rules are called "nexus", and are a lot more complicated than VAT!
[0] People love to dismiss economics as a field and disregard it's consensus, and that's their choice, but it's weird to then believe the few economists who promote UBI are right without any proof.
It is for a definition of UBI that is broader than yours (whatever that may be). Welfare is a UBI for a segment of the population. If the solutions are always the same, with a varying bar of minimum means, the people of the US have already agreed to it. What's left is to argue about degree. The emergency stimulus checks are concrete proof of that.