I understand that there is a need to protect those drivers (and other gig economy workers), but trying to bend the law's definition is not the right way to do it. This will get reversed as all other cases did.
I understand that there is a need to protect those drivers (and other gig economy workers), but trying to bend the law's definition is not the right way to do it. This will get reversed as all other cases did.
Labour Justice is its own court in Brazil. They have their own structure that only judges labour issues and they are usually very protective of employees. My guess is that this is just a form of protest by the first instance judges that do not agree with the ruling.
This, unfortunately, is very common in Labour cases in Brazil (at least it was when I stopped being a lawyer there about 3 years ago).
The law establishes that to be considered an employee/employer relationship, there needs to be a level of control from the employee's journey/hours, etc.
That control simply does not exist between Uber and Uber drivers and that is why it is considered that they fail the legal employee definition.
Obviously there is disagreement, as with everything in Law, but in this case you really need to bend the definition to make it fit the requirement.
As I said before, I fully agree that Uber drivers and other gig workers need some protection, but I also fully agree with the ruling that they do not fit the current legal objective definition of a employee/employer relationship. It simply does not.
We need new laws for those cases, or to change the legal definition (which is unlikely). Judges giving those rulings is basically having judges creating laws, which is not how it is supposed to be (by the way, Brazil does not have Common Law, so other rulings do not have the same power as in US/UK and other Common Law states).
That said... our laws get bent a lot, specially by tech companies, for example often I see offers for "Flexi" jobs, that is euphemism for registering the worker legally in one job, but paying him outside the legal framework for another job, this is obviously illegal, but is wildly popular, because our labor laws are waaaaaay too much.