Since we don't yet have the means to objectively/scientifically record what the scent actually smells like, perhaps the bottle should stay closed?
Furthermore, from what I understand, only a few microliters were removed from the bottle and it was resealed, so it is not like the sample is lost to time, and it is probably better preserved now that it is being stored in a museum than sitting on the seafloor.
I will be honest I am not thrilled that the contents are being kept a secret and used to sell overpriced perfume, but in general I am all for people reproducing relics if it means more people can be experience them!