1. Is this machine primarily used as a laptop, desktop or server?
2. Is this machine owned by a business or by a person?
All sorts of popcon results are taken as being authoritative, when (I think) the overwhelming majority of responders are personal owners with laptops or desktops.
It'll quickly and destroyed, so I just keep thinking I'll pollute their stats.
Usually what happens with opt-in versus opt-out is that the people who are the heaviest users of your software, the ones who care about it, the ones who might know its details or care about privacy will turn it off and you'll just be getting analytics from people who are casual users–and it's really easy to end up interpreting this as "hey, nobody uses $OBSCURE_FEATURE, let's remove it!". Whereas if you make it opt-in, yes you will generally have smaller numbers, but the distribution might be more useful to you, and you're less likely to think that just because you have numbers on 70% of people you're going to make the right decision.
I don't think it's "irrational" to suggest that you shouldn't be collecting data from those people as they have clearly not given consent to you doing so.