People really have to watch what Urbit is doing and understand why. Anything less is insufficient.
People really have to watch what Urbit is doing and understand why. Anything less is insufficient.
I view it in this way; all throughout the 90s and 2000s there were message boards. We used to be active on dozens of them, and each had their own account and avatar.
Each also had a little community and an admin. Each cost money to run and had to scale.
The only thing that's changed with AP is that now all those tiny communities can come together with federation. You can communicate between communities and users.
That's all! It doesn't have to be more complicated or dangerous than that.
You'll still have dedicated admins who pay for hosting with their time and money. You'll still have communities around these admins who contribute content and perhaps donations.
But to be able to communicate across communities and not have dozens of accounts is a big step forward to me.
Im looking forward to a better comparison in Q4 or Q1 2021 when Urbit is more usable for regular people though. As of now, I don’t suspect that anyone will pay $10 for a VPS and $5 for (reliable) star service.
It should be noted that when I critiqued ActivityPub here a couple months ago, a main developer of the spec was very supportive and already on top of the improvements that I was hoping for (such as being less reliant on servers, more true decentralization, etc)
Lots of features are there, it got faster, more stable.
There's no need to pay for anything. Urbit planets are usable from desktop, and don't really need to be turned on all the time. Urbit should have no problem eventually running from a phone, which is like 99% online device for me anyway.
Federation of services running on Unix machines is just not going to work. That's how Internet used to work, and it was not practical so it degenerated into what we have right now.
Great conversations with interesting people has exactly zero bearing on the quality of the project. I have had great conversations on IRC.
You do need to pay for a planet of course (because of the “skin in the game” concept that urbit people are obsessed with). But I’m speaking of paying for Star service though. Yes, stars are free now, but the whole point of Stars is that they will not be free. Otherwise they will serve you ads or do some other things to be sustainable. And in my experience, stars should be a paid service even today, because the connections are so unreliable that it is just beyond frustrating.
If Urbit is a toy, it’s a really good one. If it’s a tool for communication, it’s terrible and you’re better off with literally anything else. I mean, it doesn’t even have notifications so idk how it’s useful for a communication today.
That’s why I’m saying to just wait til Q4 or Q1 and see where it’s at.
Why are you poo pooing federation when Urbit is a federation of Stars? What are you even saying? Every decentralized mesh network today still requires a federation of relay servers. Unless you’re talking about going around the whole networking stack as it is today. But in that case, nobody would need federation and Urbit wouldn’t be the only solution for that either.
My comment is overly long already, but I feel compelled to also say that Urbit is bad for privacy today as well.
Because I own my own identity, and can move it to another star quite seamlessly without losing my ID and all connections I've made. And I'm not a second class citizen in the system because of that.
With Federated protocols I can create my own instance, sure. Then I do own my identity, at the cost of all the administrative overhead and being a second class participant. Spam and abuse are an unsolved problem at the core of the legacy Internet and all these federated protocols can't do anything about it.
If I own an instance I have to deal with it (spam and other abuse) myself, and constantly fight the fact that other people think I might be a potential abuser myself, which puts people on minor-instances at a disadvantage.
So natural economic and social forces constantly push the system to centralize and that's exactly what we're seeing with everything on the Internet.
Regarding spam and abuse, what deters that on Urbit? The cost of a planet? Planets are only as valuable as the Social capital that they’ve built up. If a planet has no mutual “friends” with me, I’m not trusting that planet, period.
I'm looking forward to see how decentralized identifiers will work in practice. It's a step in the right direction, though I don't think it will be enough on its own.
> By convention, booted addresses are expected to have some existing reputation outside of their name alone, since they’ve been used on the network. Reputation, good and bad, comes in many forms. Did the address operate any useful infrastructure? Did it get placed on any blacklists for spam or abuse? Did it simply send and receive messages? The ability to programatically track reputation is still in its infancy, but we expect the tooling to develop as urbit grows.
https://urbit.org/blog/value-of-address-space-pt3/
This is to say that you do not need limited address space or even a cost barrier to have spam prevention.
In a project that’s been around since 2012.
I was really excited to experience the new wave in computing. I found smoke and mirrors. Cool idea though.
If anything, Xanadu[^1], but that's a thought, a philosophy, and it'll probably never happen.
Even though Urbit is trying its best to prevent that?