That’s an awfully cynical take when all you have to ask is how these publications could stay afloat without drawing readers in. They’re in a tough spot when people are opting for their Facebook feed over paying for articles from proper journalists.
That’s an awfully cynical take when all you have to ask is how these publications could stay afloat without drawing readers in. They’re in a tough spot when people are opting for their Facebook feed over paying for articles from proper journalists.
Cynical? It seems accurate to me, and you even say they're in a tough spot.
The sad part is whatever drove them this direction is destroying them, but I think it came from inside, not twitter.
At least the NYT has a daily podcast, an updating podcast on the impeachment (when the impeachment happened), a podcast series on engagement algorithms in radicalizing people, I think several more. The Atlantic, The Daily Beast, NPR (So many NPR podcasts), etc. also have podcasts.
I think podcasts are well covered and this argument is coming from a place of ignorance.
I think my argument still stands, newspapers are still in the print business. Doing a quick search of other papers seems to show a trend of having a podcast as an afterthought and/or treating it as a way to deliver radio content. Putting a radio show on the internet doesn't make it a podcast. Give me a discussion, a long form interview, something real. I don't want cuts, voiceovers, musical interludes, or scripts. I'm coming down hard on the production quality because it's a sure sign that something has been editorialized to death, generally by a committee of people with competing interests and vanities. Too many cooks spoil the broth.
which market is that? Historically, US newspapers made most of their money by selling advertising. Just was with Google (and Facebook) today, the market wasn't readers - readers were the hook to get the actual customers - advertisers - to pay in.
Newspapers are not going to get that market back, no matter what they do.
In the end, that sort of journalism may need to rely on donations. We're simply no longer wired to pay for that sort of information and media. If everyone changed at once, we might be retrained to pay, but I doubt that would happen.
And if a newsroom can't do that better than somebody on social media, it should hire that person (or at least commission a piece).
I think what happened is that it turned out the real value newspapers provided wasn't the expensive high-quality content, but simply the printing and distribution which used to have immense barriers to entry. The Internet shattered those barriers to entry, and it turned out that all that people wanted was to have access to some timely shared national/regional/local content and that the cheaper content would tend to win.
I don't know man? Many have tried, all have failed. Even newsletters, in the end, write what readers want to hear. Some of the most radical and extremist information out there, is disseminated by newsletters.
I think OP hit on the crux of the issue, technology, or "the smartphone" if you want to pin it on that, has changed not only methods of consumption, but consumption behavior and expectations on a fundamental level. And I think that applies to all media, not only news. The seeming efficiency of information and media delivery on a smartphone just makes us think differently about the value of information and media. We start wanting the information we want, and we start blocking the information we don't want. After a while, information and media we don't want won't even show up for us. It's massively efficient customer service on a global scale. I'm not sure what can reasonably be done about it?
The news corporations chose money over morals. They decided to become clickbait tabloids to chase ad revenue. I don't think anything of value would be lost if we saw some of these media giants go under.
I would go further than you and say that publishing fiction based loosely on current events under the guise of “news” has negative utility, and much would be gained by getting rid of it.
That said, I don’t know how to solve this! It — along with every other case where capitalism produces suboptimal outcomes — is an example of Goodhart's law, so the issue will come back fast if we tried any simple and obvious solutions.
IMO, the money and the passion is there. I don't see why there can't be an NRA / Sierra Club / Red Cross type organization for true investigative, insightful, trustworthy journalism.
The issue is that people can already get "news" for free, so they wouldn't see the need to support such an organization. We as a society need to rebrand Fox, CNN, etc as current events based entertainment media.
> I don't think anything of value would be lost if we saw some of these media giants go under.
I do. Democracy requires citizens to know the facts at a level of understanding that is actionable. It takes a lot of work and skill to distill the chaos of mass human behavior into something that voters can make sense of and journalists are the closest we have to experts at that process.
I agree with you that good journalists are essential to society 100%. I also think that the current state of affairs is doing more harm than good. We would be better off as a society if CNN and Fox News dissolved tomorrow.
> In a capitalistic ecosystem where the fitness function is profitability, the only organizations that survive are the ones that choose money.
What about the Red Cross, the NRA, the Sierra Club, the NAACP, the ACLU? There is absolutely room in a capitalist society for non-profit organizations that at least some segment of the population are passionate about enough to fund them.
In the modern age, there is also room for independent journalists. Thousands of Youtubers and podcasters make a living through patreon, why not journalists? With the internet, you don't need to backing of a massive news outlet to have your story printed and distributed.
Good point. Yes, we are not quite living in a libertarian paradise/hellhole of pure capitalism yet. :)
Even there, though, non-profits do compete for donor dollars and the competitive pressure is not always well-aligned with the altruistic goals of the organization.
> There is absolutely room in a capitalist society for non-profit organizations that at least some segment of the population are passionate about enough to fund them.
I agree, but I hesitate to rely entirely on the largesse of those with spare cash to support journalism. Journalism is a vital function for democracy, and democracy should support all of a nations' people, not just the views of those with extra money.
There are, of course, many wealthy people willing to support journalism that protects the poor too, but I worry as always about bias.
> In the modern age, there is also room for independent journalists. Thousands of Youtubers and podcasters make a living through patreon, why not journalists? With the internet, you don't need to backing of a massive news outlet to have your story printed and distributed.
I have some but limited faith that "all bugs are shallow" applies to investigative journalism. Yes, independent journalists can dig up and find a lot of stuff. But there's really something to be said for the doors that get opened when a journalist from a well-regarded important publication knocks on them.
When the Washington Post asks a politician a hard question, they feel some pressure to answer. When J. Random Youtuber does, not so much.
In a moralistic ecosystem, you have a totalitarianism of the "morals" of whoever is in power.
I like mine, which probably significantly overlap yours in most of the ways that count. Not a big fan of Stalin's.
> In a moralistic ecosystem, you have a totalitarianism of the "morals" of whoever is in power.
All ecosystems reflect the values of those that are in power. The current capitalistic ecosystem reflects the value that maximum profit is good (in the moral sense), that one of the primary obligations of the individual is to consume products, and that you provide value to society by working a job that pays you money.
Indeed, because they are in such a tough spot, it suggests that they might be pushing towards doing unethical things in order to stay afloat.
WaPo and NYT dishonest political activism is far far worse than BuzzFeed's entertainment listicles.