However, despite that those sites will get an implicit reward - if users go to these sites, and find a slick easy checkout and low prices, the site will satisfy their need. Google's goal is to put sites that satisfy the users search request at the top.
So, assuming this new Google service is any good, then sites that use it will end up upranked just because those sites satisfy users more than other sites.
That happened in things like Google Reader - users loved the service so much the industry for RSS readers died and stagnated, hurting users...
People learn from experience and the experiences of others.
Google track record is not great in that regards.
But, no matter how much faster (or better) your page, you will never, ever, be above, or in the carousel.
How do you consider that "baseless"? It's obvious that Google rewards sites that do things the way it dictates.
Read what you write please.
What I said: You'll get up-ranked, but will always be below the carousel. Therefore being in the carousel is an unfair advantage of AMP.