It's not entirely baseless. Look at what's happening with AMP. Google aren't a charity, and at some point in the last decade they realized it.
But, no matter how much faster (or better) your page, you will never, ever, be above, or in the carousel.
How do you consider that "baseless"? It's obvious that Google rewards sites that do things the way it dictates.
Read what you write please.
What I said: You'll get up-ranked, but will always be below the carousel. Therefore being in the carousel is an unfair advantage of AMP.