Clearly the company is worried about it - for the record, when I graduated I never got an interview or even an email response from the likely company in the story.
If you're worried the rankings which place Duke above your school are incorrect and you believe your CS program was as rigorous and useful as what the Duke students have, I can understand being frustrated by that. File under "life isn't fair."
I don't think anyone is going to defend the company in the story, for all the obvious reasons.
I didn't get into Duke. I'll remember that day for the rest of my life.