> They're both tools for large power with supranational privileges for geopolitical interests. Which makes them directly comparable and functionally equivalent.
The Magnitsky acts are the US flexing its power in pursuit of human rights. The NSL is the CCP flexing its power to entrench its authoritarian hold over the Chinese diaspora and international business. That's a fundamental, moral difference.
> Drawing up a list trying to label one group good and other group bad misses the point.
No it perfectly illustrates my point. The targets of the Magnitsky acts are corrupt murderers. The targets of the NSL are democratic activists.
> Each group is bad for interest for the respective countries, that's all that matters.
Yeah but the CCP is evil, so groups that are bad for them (like democratic activists) are good.
> Also, follow the news, Magnitsky was just applied to XinJiang paramilitary organization XPCC/Bingtuan.
The CCP is committing an atrocity in Xinjiang, and the XPCC is the CCP government organization that's largely responsible. This is exactly what the Magnitsky acts are for.
> ...just slapped the act 24 hours ago on an organization with 2.4 million people
Let's have a look at what the order says:
> As a result of today’s action, all property and interests in property of the [XPCC] and individuals named above, and of any entities that are owned, directly or indirectly, 50 percent or more by them, individually, or with other blocked persons, that are in the United States or in the possession or control of U.S. persons, are blocked....
So it's not all 2.4 million XPCC members.
> US supranational instruments are being interpreted beyond their limits under this admin, especially Pompeo and his Chinahawk clique.
Pompeo is, like the rest of the free world, critical of the CCP. That's different than being a "Chinahawk".
> China announcing their own supranational instruments is overdue...
The CCP has no moral authority to do so, therefore these "instruments" are hegemonic at best.
> ...and all it does is target obviously anti-state actors...
If your idea of an anti-state actor is this kid [1], I can't take you seriously. And you should say the whole thing: "anti-authoritarian-state actors". Or, "democracy activists" is shorter.
> instead of something like the entire republican party, or entire US special operations command, which is downright restraint and responsible in comparison.
Look I'm no fan of the GOP, but if they build an insane surveillance state in order to put 1-3 million ethnic/religious minorities in concentration camps indefinitely with no charges or trials where they experience "torture, rape, sterilization, and other abuses" [2], sure, freeze their accounts.
[1]: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EeJ-eZKUEAAZ3I2.jpg
[2]: https://www.uscirf.gov/sites/default/files/China_0.pdf