The reason it confounds so many people so much is because Jews are known to be a historically oppressed people (despite exceed statistical averages for life outcomes so consistently), and white people cannot be oppressed, because they are the people who do the oppression!
In reality these contradictions only serve to highlight how stupid (and racist) it is to make those sorts of generalizations. Categorizing people by skin color is especially stupid, because the larger a group becomes, the less homogenous it becomes, and the less merit the generalizations have. Scottish, Irish and English people are all white, yet two of those groups have a rather long history of particularly horrific oppression at the hands of the 3rd. When should we start discussing reparations for the highland clearances? Should Dan Castellaneta resign from his role on The Simpson’s for so blatantly reinforcing a negative racial stereotype? Is Elon Musk America’s wealthiest African American? How much oppression does a brown-skinned African American have in common with a brown-skinned Indian immigrant?
The reason those questions sound so stupid is because the world is actually full of roughly 7.5 billion individual people, who all have their own individual circumstances, views and life experiences, and the more you try and group them together, the further you drift from reality. Especially if you’re trying to group them together for the purposes of holding some form of racial prejudice.