EDIT because I'll get HN throttled writing too many comments quickly: @smt88 Regulation can and should require providing regulators with credit scoring algorithms, and the regulation of those algorithms (starting with Fair Isaac's/FICO scoring models). This is no different than recent conversations about requiring ML models be transparent to regulators. This is what legislation is for.
For example, shopping around for good terms on a loan could hurt your credit score. Or never having borrowed, despite having a great income, somehow meant you can't buy a house.
As a lender, I'd want competition in formulas, not necessarily in the core data (the number of loans a person has now and their history of payments).
> despite having a great income, somehow meant you can't buy a house.
The correlation between income, credit score, and risk is weaker than you might think. High-income people can also outspend their ability to repay. [0] Banks can use income to rule out a mortgage application, but that number is not useful for measuring the converse, because spending varies widely.
> For example, shopping around for good terms on a loan could hurt your credit score.
Credit bureaus do account for this, because as you might guess, shopping around does not correlate with credit risk. Usually this is done by counting only one application per time window. (45 days in the case of FICO) But, even then, hard hits on your credit are typically weighted very low. The reason it matters at all outside of that window is because they want to identify people who are, for instance, applying for new credit every 6 months because they are in financial trouble and digging themselves a hole of debt.
[0]: https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/notes/feds-notes/are-...
On the latter example, would you lend vast sums of money to someone who has never demonstrated their ability to manage and repay a loan?
> On the latter example, would you lend vast sums of money to someone who has never demonstrated their ability to manage and repay a loan?
I think this is a misunderstanding of the role of debt in the world today. Access to debt is all but a necessity to have any hope of financial stability. Prices of large costs like housing and college tuition have increased in massive surplus of the average person's ability to pay for them, which in many ways is a huge problem in and of itself, but the only way the system even sort of still works is easy access to debt.
In these circumstances it really doesn't make sense to just shrug it off and let some people fall through the cracks with no recourse because the antiquated and opaque system didn't approve them.
There are plenty of free options to get your real FICO score - discover gives it, Experian has a free plan. They give you your FICO score + summary of the report.
Creditors don't use that... First, shopping for a loan usually involves soft-pulls of your report and that gives you an interest rate and general idea if you get approved or not. Then you satisfied with rate and decide to proceed with loan - hard pull happens, this one gets recorded. Important thing - they pull your entire credit history, not just score, in fact there is no way to pull score. Then they either approve you or ask for more documentation like: bank statement, pay stubs, W2, etc. You can have 700s credit score while being deep in debt. Also, my FICO score was always higher than my Vantage score, not other way around.
Even paid Experian cost like 15$ a month and it shows you all your FICO scores: general, auto, house lending, banking etc. It's dumb to start shopping for a mortgage relying on just CK vantage score.
Easy access to debt financing drives up those prices. If people can't afford purchases w/o incurring debt and loans aren't available, prices would fall.
Instead, you're advocating making it easier for people take loans that exceed their ability to pay?
That's not rational from either a borrower, a lender, or a systemic perspective.
It goes beyond "there is no 'your score'" – there are absolutely credit scores that really matter, it's just the overwhelming majority of people who monitor their "score" from a free monitoring site are looking at something that may be at best a poor simulation of that score.
From what I've learned from a friend who did banking software development for decades: almost every lender pulls a FICO score from all three reporting agencies, discards the high and low, and uses the middle score to make their lending decision. In some cases lenders go out of their way to avoid building in manual underwriting because the score is typically quite accurate and manual underwriting allows bias to enter the system that may open up fair lending/housing lawsuits.
Credit Karma doesn't provide a FICO score. Most places that give you "free credit scores" don't. My friend says they jokingly call this a FAKO – a fake FICO. It means next to nothing because they tend to be based on an alternative model like VantageScore that isn't what lenders use to make decisions.
If you want a real FICO score, you can buy them from myfico.com and get them from all three bureaus, or you can get a credit card that gives you one: all Discover cards give a monthly FICO 8 from TransUnion and AMEX gives a FICO 8 from Experian (not sure if it's all the cards, and don't go to the "give my credit score" link on their site – you have to find the link to your FICO score)
His tl;dr: "a site that tells you your credit score means nothing, a site that tells you your FICO score means a great deal".
Yes, of course. I don't think paying off a loan requires practice. You don't become more trustworthy or responsible just because you borrow money.
In fact, someone without loans (and high income) suggests they take loans seriously and don't want to live riskily.
> would you lend vast sums of money to someone who has never demonstrated their ability to manage and repay a loan?
Banks seem very comfortable lending it to guys who talk the talk regardless of their ability to repay. Hell we have on such trickster in the whitehouse, now. These rules only apply to the rich and the upper-middle class (the ones who really caused the financial loan industry to collapse in 2008).
Depends on what they're borrowing for. If it's real estate, the valuation is solid, and the borrower has a reliable income, why not? They're obviously either well-resourced or financially responsible or both, since they've previously never needed a loan. That plus the existence of an underlying asset that can be taken back sounds like a low risk deal for the bank.
Also, don't mortgage applications look at your savings and other assets when lending? It's not just the credit score right?
It actually may be that deregulation could also work, as with many things we've found the worst of all worlds where there's just enough regulation to keep out any real competition and not enough to actually protect anyone other than a few lobbied interests. But deregulation would be a much riskier approach, whereas there is a pretty clear, minimally invasive path forward for regulation to solve a lot of these issues.
In addition to the things you suggest, I also think more regulation around what kinds of recurring bills should and should not be considered debt, and stricter rules around things being sent to collections. Right now, if e.g. you have a $30 utility bill for a partial month of service on your previous residence, the provider can send it to collections without really making any reasonable effort contact you. There are also predatory recurring bills that can be incredibly difficult to cancel and that turn into debt if you forget about them. At a bare minimum, physical mail shouldn't be sufficient notification that an account is past due, creditors should have to make some kind of reasonable effort to contact you that is consistent with modern social mores. There are lots of rules that could be put in place to better protect consumers from accidentally having their credit ruined. I really don't believe that a young person being a little bit careless, or not understanding the intricacies of the credit system and what is at stake, has anything to do with whether they are capable of making payments on a major purchase like a home years later.
The companies have certain parameters for who they want to advertise to and CK shows you ads and gets a commission. Your data would only be shared if you initiated a transaction with the advertiser.
Whether that makes the situation better is a judgment call. But, your data is never shared without your permission.