Then there are the knock-on social mobility benifits such as being able to switch jobs without having to move your family. Or, at a lower level, not having to rent your house/appartment/shack from your employer. Many people see cars as evil today, but realize that today is not yesturday.
Of course we don't really have traffic problems, but I wonder how we are supposed to build similar amounts of infrastructure?
Should we stop living here and move somewhere with more people?
Vastly enhanced point-to-point mobility seems like a pretty clear upside to me. Absent cars, public transportation would doubtless be better. But people would have far less flexibility in where they lived, where they went for recreation, and in many other things.
Sparing use? Buses, perhaps, emergency vehicles, and possibly delivery trucks? Probably a solid, significant improvement. Individual automobile use on public streets in and around urban areas, and all the adjustments necessary for that to happen or consequent of car-influenced growth patterns? Way, way murkier than one might initially expect, but now very expensive and difficult to reverse regardless, so we're stuck spending a lot more to travel farther and save, if we buy cheap cars and have a high paying job, a little time.
Walking and bicycles provide no protection from the elements. Depending on where you live and your occupation, the ability to travel in climate-controlled conditions and arrive with your work clothes unsoiled can be a massive utility benefit.
>>once a city's adjusted its girth to account for cars, the points most often factoring into ones point-to-point mobility are much farther apart than they'd have been without adjustments made due to widespread use of cars. Notably this doesn't include only people choosing to move farther apart, but everything being pushed apart by large setbacks from unpleasant roads
I'd argue that the land area dedicated to roads is a small portion of what forces businesses apart, and that low-density construction and inherently smaller buildings is the major contributing factor. There's only so many shops you can fit into 3-story buildings with narrow footpath-like streets between them. Hanoi is a good example of that. 48QWJ8705424314 (MGRS, paste into Google Maps)
I think the flexibility would still exist, but with a different layout
But I quickly read through the entire thing (JSTOR still has free access: cool!) and AFAICT automobiles were far more dangerous than horses, both in absolute fatalities and presumably even more so adjusting for the number of horses and cars per capita. Toward the end the author tacks on train and streetcar deaths just to make automobile deaths look better. Indeed, it's not until the very end where the author isn't constantly drawing conclusions and providing anecdotes that seemingly contradict his own hard data. Only on a per mile basis, and then only a few decades into the age of the automobile (i.e. after traffic controls become common and pedestrians become persona non grata on the street), are automobiles indisputably safer.
Considering the utter lack of almost all traffic controls prior to the automobile and the way that pedestrians intermixed with horses, the figures are actually astonishing. More astonishing when you look at train and streetcar deaths, which were apparently incredibly lethal. I'm glad I found that paper because almost all other sources I found--which completely lacked any hard evidence--claimed horses were far more dangerous. (So does this one, though the data suggests otherwise.)
Twice. From 7yo to his early sixties. Given that horses are active participants in traffic and they will go out of their way to not step on you, they would seem to be orders of magnitude safer compared to cars.
Besides, I'd expect a professional cowboy to know how to protect himself from horses, just like a professional driver is going to have fewer car accidents.
This might be a controversial opinion but I think that's a big plus. Look at old European cities with tiny streets that were mostly designed in times before carriages & cars; vs modern American cities (e.g. upper Manhattan) with large streets, a lot of driving and walking space, etc. Sure, the European model might be more romantic but the US one is definitely more functional (density isn't an issue either; London is much less dense than Manhattan).