Given that I personally believe that schools, roads and hospitals are necessities for modern society and you appear to believe that these are some kind of false consciousness, I'm not sure how we can carry on this discussion.
Given that I personally believe that schools, roads and hospitals are necessities for modern society and you appear to believe that these are some kind of false consciousness, I'm not sure how we can carry on this discussion.
Just on the roads point, without a government, we might all be flying personal helicopters, no roads required.
And it's not they (unless you're stateless or an immigrant), it's we. We pay taxes so that our delegates (government) can provide us services. It's a worthy trade, in my belief at least.
Of course we don't know what might or might not occur, if the situation were different. But the fact is that neither you nor I decided on roads. The government decided. I don't see what's weak about that.
The government is 'they', its not 'we' (though you may identify with its actions). I want no part of it, but despite my lack of agreement with anything that it does, it is inflicted on me anyway. I am coerced to pay taxes. You are in agreement with a system where a big gang can use their superior numbers to force another person to do what they say, despite that other person having done them no wrong.
So, seriously, if you have a counter argument, please go ahead and make it. Please explain what number or percentage of people makes it ok to force another person to part with 40% of their income against their will. I'd like to hear your argument. Be sure to explain the difference between government tax and mafia protection money too.
Cheers.