I used to have to bus through that region every single day (I don't miss the 72 Cherry one bit).
Managing privacy permissions of anyone just commuting through would be a logistical nightmare—and not just for Sidewalk.
Sounds like an instance of what this comment describes: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24123463
As for the rest, I'm not much of a gambler.
Alphabet's current policies on data collection are typically opt-out, so I didn't hold out much hope when I largely saw a lot of hand-waving surrounding data policies until the project was pressed by the public about it. That cost me a lot of confidence the project.
And I come from the place of following the project eagerly at the start. Even looked for jobs with them at one point.
I'm not getting into any arguments today.