Less than 1% of energy comes from wind and solar and we aren't looking at more than 3-4% in 2030. Wind and solar require either nuclear, gas, coal and oil as backup. Nuclear is completely out of vogue and will take years to build.
It's not just concrete and air travel it's ships, trucks, steel production, anything that require large amount of heat.
You can't power a hospital based on solar and wind etc.
Fossil fuels are not going anywhere until we either get fusion or some sort of fuel cell technology, but they require som fundamental breakthroughs we aren't close to meeting just yet.
The problem is doing things at scale not just proving in some lab what is theoretically possible.
We will have fusion before we have wind and solar covering just 50% of the worlds energy consumption.
And of course we won't be fucked. Climate catastrophism is the last thing we need.
I've worked in one industrial plant, and they mostly just needed power and steam to run the processing equipment.
If you need oil as a chemical input, you could offset that carbon or likely synthesize it. But even just reducing our fossil oil use to ingredients and not fuel would make a massive difference.
That seems like a rather imprecise and thereby meaningless refutation of the parent's point.
IMO a more honest statement of that idea would be:
"Not if you want to live a totally unconstrained life, drawing on all currently available benefits, whether neccessary or not".
I do think, that "modern life" would be compatible with zero CO2 emission (for some definition of "modern life"), people would merely have to face more constraints and regulation.
- More pubic transit on trains - Less packaging and throw away plastic utensils so you might have to carry a fork with you or employ more dishwashers at restaurants - Less meat and fish consumption, returning America to its more traditional diets modulo beyond meat type substitutes. - More local production and transport instead of shipping things across the world - Less non-essential work and the travel accompanying it - More urbanization to make ecological systems more efficient - Use of LED lighting systems - Less "fast fashion" and wearing more durable clothing - Use of electric heat wherever possible - Widespread battery production - Global solar network to ship sunlight power around the world - Emphasizing power efficiency in electronics
Some of these changes are fairly disruptive, but extremely mild compared to the challenges humans have faced in history such as war and starvation.
Keep in mind that these so-called "modern lifestyles" that are most carbon intensive are lived most vibrantly by the wealthy (e.g. private jets, endless consumption of materials). Many people will not be hugely inconvenienced compared to their current life circumstances.
Personally I would always want to factor in some sort of ROI for the conversation to have any meaningful context.
There are many ways we can "fix" things but the cost of the fix should always be measured against what it is fixing.