Also, patronizing. And quite possibly mistaken. I mean, how do you know what was in US flour in 1914? It was legal to mix it with chalk dust and cornstarch not very far before that, and I think it still was in 1914: http://query.nytimes.com/gst/abstract.html?res=F20810FB3D5C1...
http://www.rsc.org/education/eic/issues/2005mar/thefightagai... claims:
To whiten bread, for example, bakers sometimes added
alum (…) and chalk to the flour, while mashed potatoes,
plaster of Paris (calcium sulphate), pipe clay and even
sawdust could be added to increase the weight of their
loaves. Rye flour or dried powdered beans could be used
to replace wheat flour and the sour taste of stale flour
could be disguised with ammonium carbonate.
Anyway, so at the time, I think there were already a lot of food additives in use. They just weren't systematically vetted for toxicity the way they are today.> However, yesterday when I opened a box of flour that I'd ordered from the internet, I realised that it made me feel kinda snobby. Why do I order flour off the internet? Protein content. Read this:
Thank you! That was awesome! I had no idea.
> carboxymethyl cellulose, carageenan, guar gum, xanthan gum, agar, pectin or maltodextrin.
It's true that those are common additives, and as you say that they are generally not unhealthy (those are all fiber, protein, or a mixture of the two, aren't they? Except maltodextrin, which is a starch), but they are usually a tiny fraction of the food.
> Real, good food that is made the proper way doesn't need to be thickened, bulked up or stabilized.
I don't agree. I use cornstarch, arrowroot, or even white flour as bulking and thickening agents when I make real, good food the proper way, and I often use milk, mustard, or egg as stabilizers. I've used lemon peel as a stabilizer too when I made blackberry jam, because it contains pectin. I don't know how you propose we should make blackberry jam without adding stabilizers?
I don't know of any reason to believe that the more popular food additives you list are any more dangerous than the traditional ones I usually use. I just don't happen to have them in my pantry or have experience cooking with them. (Indeed, many traditional additives like sassafras and lead sugar have been discovered to be toxic in the last couple of centuries, but to my knowledge, there still hasn't been a systematic testing program.)
I recognize that you're probably a lot more experienced at cooking than I am, so maybe I'm totally off the wall here. Enlighten me!