Note that the ignorance of the previous generation is not said as a slight. I'm sure my children's generation will be rolling their eyes at the things I say and do 20-30 years from now.
Note that the ignorance of the previous generation is not said as a slight. I'm sure my children's generation will be rolling their eyes at the things I say and do 20-30 years from now.
Maybe, but that's off-topic. I don't think anybody is claiming that this is "frivolous". It's a real case, based on alleged violation of real laws. There's a real question at stake, whether the defendant's usage of the IP was Fair Use.
(IANAL, this isn't legal advice).
It's tedious, but if there's one and only one thing that law taught me, it's a habit of professional paranoia.
Also, you mentioned that as an ex-law student you must be careful? Is there any special status associated with ever studying law that makes you more susceptible to such charges rather than say, if you had studied history or math?
> if there's one and only one thing that law taught me, it's a habit of professional paranoia.
You might make a good security researcher then ;-)
In short: To give unqualified advice, you must first be qualified.
However, one thing that is rarely reported, and I'd like to know, is how much the defendants in this case had to spend on lawyers to get these trolls to go away. If they had to spend a lot of money, and didn't recover it, that's a loss. Plus, how much time loss and personal stress/unhappiness did this lawsuit cost them?
If a court system drags you through the dirt and bleeds you dry to get a ruling that most people would agree is common sense, well, that's better than a bad ruling, but it's still a kind of fail.
(Case in point: The Sony v Hotz settlement)
News is about the exceptions to the rule. "Everything Normal" does not make an interesting headline.
This is only from my own experience at law school. There were relatively few truly tech-savvy folks out there. Almost everyone I knew still used Microsoft Word to type their lecture notes and outlines. (MS Word is terrible for this purpose - its internal formatting gets weird after a certain amount of bullet points.) I used special software for my lecture notes from a startup, and other students viewed me as "weird". I was also the first law student to use Dropbox to back up my work - seriously. (There were some other law students who were programmers before, but they are a different class of lawyers.)
I'm not entirely sure that a legion of new lawyers who know how to use MS Word, computers and the internet are "technologically-savvy". More tech-savvy than old lawyers? absolutely. Compared to the rest of society? Eh.