David Kerr, the defense laywer, was going to file numerous motions to dismiss/ change venues. That would have ran up the copyright troll's legal bills. I suspect that the judge would have happily gone along with Kerr's plan, but who knows?
Doesn't really matter in this case anyway. The mere threat of actual litigation scared Righthaven away.
Hill's attorney had two things in mind:
1. If Hill won, it'd have been very bad for RightHaven.
2. If RightHaven backed down, it'd be good for Hill.
3. If RightHaven won and got a large judgement against Hill, the outrage would be huge. But Hill would still be up for the bill.
So if Hill won, or Righthaven backed down, great for Hill. But if Righthaven won an obscene judgment plus costs against Hill, he could simply ignore it. Righthaven's only recourse would be to spend more money obtaining a bankruptcy order against him which would:
1. Probably have no practical impact on Hill, a mentally an physically disabled single man with no assets; and 2. Still not result in Righthaven recovering any money.
If the system needs reform, then reform the system. But a judge shouldn't be prematurely taking sides against a litigant who's playing by the rules as they currently exist.
Not technically, but as the article says, if the plaintiff takes no steps to mitigate the damages he's supposedly suffering, but goes straight for the defendant's wallet without asking for so much as a preliminary injunction, it's reasonable to suspect his motives.