Why dumb? Admittedly I don't like the common phrasing of "pick 2". I much prefer: "in the face of a partition, a system can be consistent or available, but not both."
If you can warranty high availability (by other means) then you can focus on consistency.
It also says that you should design your data so that becoming partitioned is not a problem.
What it doesn’t do, particularly, is help us build them.