Even I believe that one. It really didn't help when public health officials banned outdoor gatherings, but BLM protests were OK.
Even I believe that one. It really didn't help when public health officials banned outdoor gatherings, but BLM protests were OK.
"Likewise, while it is possible that the protests caused an increase in the spread of COVID-19 among those who attended the protests, we demonstrate that the protests had little effect on the spread of COVID- 19 for the entire population of the counties with protests during the more than five weeks following protest onset."
It comes across as blatantly partisan and not the least bit driven by the science.
I could understand reducing the attendance at the US Open to a lower level. But to set it to zero while not doing the same for any protests... it undermines credibility.
Also, consider another example.
New York State imposed a travel quarantine on those traveling from other states. Well, except for the MTV Music Awards. Those don't count.
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/mtv-video-music-awards-new-york...
Why? Because I think the political sensibilities of the award recepients better aligns with those who granted this waiver. This creates an aire of political favoritsm. It's very damaging.
Nevertheless, I agree with the larger point that leadership should have provided more outdoor activities to draw people away from bars and restaurants.
> it is possible that the protests caused an increase in the spread
> had little effect
I don't know what you're quibbling over. If we're reaching for absolute zero levels of covid spread, then sure protests had a giant effect (just from logic). That's not practical; people need to go outside.
And per the "it is possible that the protests caused an increase in the spread" is in reference to the article's earlier hypothesis that because people were leaving their homes to protest, you would expect them to get covid at a higher rate than someone who never left their house. The article didn't have any direct evidence that that was actually the case though.
Religious gatherings typically rely on private property that is subject to health and safety standards. Protests don't typically happen in or on property that is subject to those standards.
IMHO the greatest factor is using steroids and non invasive methods instead of ventilators. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/sep/06/why-is-it-that...
Recent studies point (some say 3 times the number of infected, others 6-24 times) in the direction that we severely undercounted the infected because of its asymptomatic nature in healthy individuals.
Which means the death rate is nothing to cry about.
You can expect 3 million and a change funerals each year with a population like us.
https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid19/excess_deaths.htm
How and why did you form that belief? That just doesn't make sense.
Covid Survival Rate:
0-19 years - 99.997%
20-49 years - 99.98%
50-69 years - 99.5%
70+ years - 94.6%
What a complete nonsense argument.
What is different about covid that means we shouldn't try to treat it? We treat cancer, and genetic diseases, and the flu. We actively try to avoid death for a million other reasons. Why should we just throw our hands up with this one and act like it's not there?
Why don't you 'do something' about car crash victims every year? Are you okay with all of them dying from something that is preventable? You're just going to throw your hands in the air? Of course not. Have them wear seat belts. Invent things to reduce deaths, like airbags. But it is possible to go too far, like closing every street in the country.
There certainly were various BLM supporters who argued the protests were more important than certain covid-19 restrictions.
But that wasn't the CDC. I don't believe the CDC changed its guidance to allow for BLM protests.
Ultimately as a hypocrisy it’s small frys compared to the tidal wave of misinformation and intentionally damaging information, as well as the incompetent response and outright pitting of states against each other, compared to the current administrators actions during COVID as a whole.
TLDR; America’s response to COVID has been a relentless failure compared to all other western countries of similar size and demographics (outside of MAYBE Brazil) such that exaggeration and hypocrisy towards a small number of social gatherings is utterly insignificant by comparison.