What a wonderful post to be able to read and not have to wonder how much of it will hold up given a little time.
What a wonderful post to be able to read and not have to wonder how much of it will hold up given a little time.
When I start playing with something, once the number of papercuts I'm tracking in my head gets above 2–3, then I crack open a fresh notes.markdown file adjacent to the source repo (if there is one) and start recording all my thoughts in the vein of[1], including everything from outright bugs to opportunities for UI improvement. If the project has reasonable bugtracking infrastructure, I'll file them—or for small projects, I'll email the author along with any patches—but since most projects don't, I mostly don't end up doing anything with them. I've often thought that it would be nice if this exercise of "Let's Critique" became a thing, though. If nothing else, it could provide fuel for folks' blogs that have been lying dormant since that one post from 2017.
1. https://pointersgonewild.com/2019/11/02/they-might-never-tel...
I generally take breathless coverage of how brilliant some new language (or tech stack) is with a large pinch of salt. The foibles and pitfalls of modern languages are often hard to spot until people have code-bases that are at least a couple of years old. I think the good stuff is generally easier to see at first, while the problems (which are often consequences/side-effects of the good aspects) generally take longer to appear.
Programming languages seem to follow a variation of the Gartner Hype Cycle, with the twist that just after you get to the Plateau of Productivity and lots of people are quietly getting stuff done with it everyone starts to declare that "language X is dead/dying".
Unless a feature of the language is game-changing for you. This might mean it solves a problem that would be very hard to solve otherwise or it might mean it looks very interesting to you.
Which I think is good advice with anything that requires you to be an early adoptor.
Elixir is great at what it does, but I wouldn't use it for building a CLI tool or something like that.
After thirty-something years of programming I've seen numerous languages (or model) touted as the one true language that will save us all.
Otherwise reviews are pointless things like the packaging quality and shipment speed.
I agree with you though that a lot of reviews are useless fluff like shipping speed and packaging, and that there should be a better way to evaluate products.