Indeed, I just checked portfolio visualizer, which gives a 1997-2020 return of 8.5% CAGR for the 500. My guess is you started adding in 2007 (so your principal was very small during the great financial crisis) and you've been adding during the entire recovery. You don't know how lucky you are. Of course, maybe you just bought QQQ in 1997. Again, you don't know how lucky you are.
The number of fallacious assumptions embedded in your syllogism is difficult to unpack. I'll start with one, past returns are not indicative of futures results. I'll add another, the relative expensiveness of stocks at a given point in time are negatively correlated to long-term future returns. Someone won a nobel prize by illustrating the last one.