The timing is interesting, though. Barrett's faith has been under intense scrutiny through the confirmation process. If the Catholic church moves on this issue, will she lose the support of evangelical voters?
The timing is interesting, though. Barrett's faith has been under intense scrutiny through the confirmation process. If the Catholic church moves on this issue, will she lose the support of evangelical voters?
The activist politically conservative segment of the Catholic faithful tends to be in line with the political right and out of line with the Church heirarchy on a number of policy issues (just different issues than the activist left within the Church is, naturally), the heirarchy moving in a leftward direction on an issue where they were previously in line just adds one issue to that list, it doesn't move the position of conservative Catholic activists like Barret. Not in the short-term, and probably not much in the long term, except insofar as it increases the likelihood of such activists separating from the Church altogether (though, of course, from the PoV of such activists it will be the earthly heirarchy separating itself from the genuine Church), and thus no longer being regarded as Catholic conservatives.
Apostolic constitutions are legislation, not communiqués. And (outside of the State of Vatican City), the papal legislative authority doesn't extend to the content of civil law, which is the subject matter here.
An exhortation on a matter like civil law which is prudential on its face but on which the moral teaching of the Church has important impacts would probably be addressed, in a more formal context, in a papal encyclical or apostolic exhortation.
EDIT [1] here's a very different perspective on its significance:
https://twitter.com/JamesMartinSJ/status/1318970487242956801
EDIT [2] to merge a separate response:
> If the Catholic church moves on this issue, will she lose the support of evangelical voters?
While the politically activist Christian Right has made tactical alliance with conservative Catholics on many issues, anti-Catholicism is historically very strong among American evangelicals and fundamentalists, so, and neither politically liberal nor politically conservative Catholics in the electorate seem to move, and certainly not rapidly if they do at all, in response to policy shifts by the Church heirarchy, so I expect to have very little impact on the Barret confirmation, either the Senate process or public support one way or another for it.
Exactly. This pope has said many controversial things. For example this: https://www.thedrinksbusiness.com/2020/04/pope-francis-censo...