Yep.
I wonder where this will go defensively in court if it gets there.
I guess what the RIAA is really saying is that murder is legal depending on what was used to kill someone.
A hunting knife could be used to kill someone but it could also be used to slice a pizza pie. A pizza cutter was designed to slice pizza but it could also kill someone without too much effort.
If it's not ok for youtube-dl to create an mp3 of a music video but it is ok for OBS to do the same then it must also be ok to decapitate someone with a pizza cutter[0].
[0]: Do not try this. I'm not a lawyer.