What, exactly, does "sending your IP all around the internet" even mean?
Donkeyporn's DNS provider, com's DNS provider (0.1% chance it's not already cached), your ISP, transit providers, donkeyporn's ISP, donkeyporn service
To: cloudflare, your ISP, transit providers, donkeyporn's ISP, donkeyporn service
It's not a huge change and it's really about whether you trust CloudFlare more than the service donkeyporn has chosen.
I personally feel that concentrating all the information of "what DNS names are people looking up" into the hands of a few parties (e.g. CloudFlare) makes it much easier to collect and analyze this information.