Their claim is simply incorrect. Copyright does not protect ideas. Claiming that they can infect ideas with the GPL is bizarre and deceptive bullying.
I think, it's less this, and more preventing others as passing these ideas as their own. Which is valid. I've seen sleazier academics just CnP things without attribution.
When you submit a paper to a journal, you don't get to pick your reviewers. In fact, you most likely don't ever get to know who the reviewers are because the process is anonymized.
But given that many areas of scientific inquiry are highly specialized, it isn't particularly surprising that if you rip off someone's work, that someone is going to be picked as a reviewer for your paper by chance.