Fauci has corrected it multiple times after and said that yes you should wear masks.
https://www.factcheck.org/2020/05/outdated-fauci-video-on-fa...
And comparing the CDC to a street drug dealer is beyond asinine.
He says that if there is an outbreak, it might make people feel better to wear a mask... among other incriminating things
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ssiLlfGT9gg&t=6m22s
He also says that he was wrong in saying that masks don't prevent the spreading of the virus
I don't see this is incriminating. Computer security is not perfclty secure, and in the same way masks arent perfect. He took the academic approach of saying they aren't perfect without clarifying that its better than zero masks. Either way, his statements had unintended consequences and was dumb to take the academic approach
which it was not.... incriminating in that sense.
And just for everyone who didn't read the link: Fauci absolutely did advise "no universal masking". The position was reversed in early April, by which time the damage was done.
I think Fauci was trying to avoid a mask shortage that would have affected healthcare workers who absolutely need the masks. The problem is that he downplayed the masks too much, and now his words are being used against him.
EDIT: The video was in another comment. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PRa6t_e7dgI
Taiwan: 609 cases (7 deaths)
US: 12 million cases (250k deaths)
Their metro stayed open while we're telling people to not go sit in the park.
Taiwan was hit earlier, Taiwan is closer and denser, Taiwan has many travelers to and from Mainland China. There was one right answer. None of this "they were trying to avoid" shit. They just solved the problem. This is the sort of thing it's not good enough to try. You have to be good enough to do it. Clearly what we did is we put a bunch of Pee Wee Leaguers in the MLB and we got the socks knocked out of us. The lesson isn't "they tried". The lesson is "next time, get the A players".
The one thing that this has taught us is that the Anna Karenina Principle applies pretty well to national organizations. All the guys who did well did it the same way. Everyone who sucked, sucked in their own way.
Scooter travel is the most common form of transportation and it's very normal to wear masks to prevent inhaling pollution. You could find masks all over the place. They sell them at convenience stores, stationary stores, in vending machines at the front of hospitals, etc.
I agree there are a lot of lessons that can be learned from Taiwan's success but I'm not sure it's fair to compare their mask adherence to other nations that didn't already have that embedded in their daily lives.
Remember when a smart guy changed his opinion and you stopped harping on him for being kinda wrong that one time? Me neither.
It's incredible the amount of slack this total incompetent has gotten, just by contrast of standing next to the president.
There was no change in available data on mask efficacy on either side of the great switch in recommendations.
A quarter million Americans died for this mistake.
The already small stock of masks would have been consumed much much earlier than how it happened.
I'm sure we can come up with infinite hypotheticals. But East Asia beat this. So we don't have to hypothesize. We know what the right approach is and they showed us in freaking February!
I am going to copy it for you to show you how the A-players do it:
New Year's Eve: Rumours of viral pneumonia in Wuhan. All inbound flights from Wuhan subject to inspection
Jan 5: All Wuhan travelers exhibiting upper respiratory inspections are now subject to screening
Jan 20: First positive test
Jan 21: Mask export ban, production ramp-up
Jan 31: Taiwanese government forced monopsony on masks (1/3 reserved for healthcare personnel). Announces rationing first week of Feb
Feb 2: Taiwanese defence personnel dispatched to bolster staffing at mask factories
Feb 6: Mask rationing starts
Feb 15: Mask production by end of month projected to be 10 million / day. Taiwanese population: 24 million
Mar 9: Mask production 9.2 million / day
Mar 16: Production 10 million / day
Mar 22: Production 12.6 million / day
April 3. Taiwan: Population 24 million. Density: 649 people/sq.km. First case: Jan 20. Cases: 348. Deaths: 5
April 3. Florida: Population 21.5 million. 136.5 people/sq.km. First case: Mar 7. Cases: 10268. Deaths: 170
Did we have to make the choice between the economy and lives? Did we have to choose between grandma and the dollar? Could policy have changed the outcome?
You decide.
How can that be true if masks were already a highly available everyday product in metropolitan areas in e.g. China. Many people wore masks in winter almost every day even if they were not sick due to lower air quality.
It is indeed true that they raised already existing capacities massively up, but compared to what has been produced in the US or in Europe they already had a starting point magnitudes higher.
https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2029717
The study was not large. Another study found similarly close rates of infection for mask vs no mask:
https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326/M20-6817
From this CDC report we can see that despite widespread mask usage there is infection(as we are seeing in general)
https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/pdfs/mm6936a5-H.pdf
Each of these studies have their own issues such as small sample sizes and self reporting. We need more data and studies to make an informed decisions.
Agreed. Which is why I choose to wear a mask in public. Wearing it may help, and doesn't hurt. At worst, it is mildly inconvenient.
Your second statement is subjective. Regarding your first statement, there are real and potential negatives:
Airflow restrictions on people with COPD/asthma, fogging glasses can cause vision obstruction, tendency to draw closer to hear conversation, false sense of safety, skin irritation, infection if not properly washed, to name a few.